Musical (2010)


Musique: Andrew Lloyd Webber
Paroles: Glenn Slater
Livret: Glenn Slater
Production à la création:

"I really do not believe that you have to have seen Phantom of the Opera to understand Love Never Dies. I really don’t. But I hope if you see them together, if you wanted to see them back-to-back, that what you would get from them — from both of them — is the extension of where the story goes.“
Andrew Lloyd Webber

Version 1

Love never dies (2010-03-Adelphi Theatre-London)

Type de série: Original
Théâtre: Adelphi Theatre (Londres - Angleterre)
Durée : 1 an 5 mois 2 semaines
Nombre :
Première Preview : lundi 22 février 2010
Première : mardi 09 mars 2010
Dernière : samedi 27 août 2011
Mise en scène : Jack O'Brien
Chorégraphie : Jerry Mitchell
Producteur :
Avec : Ramin Karimloo (Phantom ), Sierra Boggess (Christine Daaé), Joseph Millson (Raoul), Liz Robertson (Mme Giry), Summer Strallen (Meg), Niamh Perry (Fleck), Adam Pearce (Squelch), Jami Reid-Quarrell (Gangle)
Commentaires : The musical opened with previews on 22nd February 2010, originally directed by Jack O’Brien and with lyrics by Glenn Slater. Although it was praised for its lavish staging, and received a few excellent notices, it was generally felt to be clunky and exceptionally dark and gloomy. It was rapidly nicknamed “Paint Never Dries”. Later in the year a new version was rehearsed simultaneously with the evening performances and the show closed for four days in November 2010 for substantial re-writes. It re-opened with new direction from Bill Kenwright, new choreography from Bill Deamer, and some new lyrics by Charles Hart. The London production closed on 27 August 2011 after a disappointing run of fewer than eighteen months.
Presse : "There is much to enjoy in Andrew Lloyd Webber's new musical. The score is one of the composer's most seductive. Bob Crowley's design and Jack O'Brien's direction have a beautiful kaleidoscopic fluidity. And the performances are good. The problems lie within the book, chiefly credited to Lloyd Webber himself and Ben Elton, which lacks the weight to support the imaginative superstructure...In short, the show has much to commend it and the staging is a constant source of iridescent pleasure. But, as one of the lyrics reminds us, 'diamonds never sparkle bright unless they are set just right'. Although Lloyd Webber's score is full of gems, in the end a musical is only as good as its book. With a libretto to match the melodies, this might have been a stunner rather than simply a good night out."
Michael Billington for The Guardian

"Dismally implausible plot...The blogosphere has been teeming with views of Lloyd Webber’s long-awaited Phantom II. For some, Love Never Dies is 'Paint Never Dries', and for others the composer is at his musical best. I tend to agree with both factions....Bob Crowley (Designs] successfully evokes much of Phantasma, helped by projections of spooky horses on carousels. Yet that’s all rather cursory, as is the choreography, which doesn’t amount to a lot more than the inevitable bathing beauties bouncing about on the beach. "
Benedict Nightingale for The Times

"Lloyd Webber’s finest show since the original Phantom, with a score blessed with superbly haunting melodies and a yearning romanticism that sent shivers racing down my spine....The show may ultimately prove too strange, too dark, too tormented to become a massive popular hit, but I suspect its creepy allure will linger potently in the memory when frothier shows have been long forgotten. "
The Daily Telegraph

"What is in no doubt is the technical excellence of Jack O'Brien's seamlessly fluent, sumptuous (and sometimes subtle) production, or the splendour of the orchestra which pours forth Lloyd Webber's dark-hued, yearning melodies as if its life depended on them."
Paul Taylor for The Independent

"It doesn’t really smoke into life until the 20th minute and even then it splutters for a while. Finally, the singing and the ingenious staging combine to show the Lloyd Webber orchestration to its full glory, but, boy, it takes an age."
Quentin Letts for The Daily Mail

"While Lloyd Webber’s music is at times lavishly operatic, the tone is uneven. There are no more than a couple of songs that promise to live in the memory, the duets don’t soar, and the ending is insipid. Admirers of Phantom are likely to be disappointed, and there’s not enough here to entice a new generation of fans."
Henry Hitchings for The Evening Standard

"Sets and special effects cannot be faulted, the singing is terrific...a stunning ending. But phantastic? Afraid not."
Bill Hagerty for The Sun

"Musically, it is pleasing enough...Visually, the show is stunning in places."
Matthew Hemley for The Stage

"This is an elegant and clever sequel to Phantom...It is a great night out."
Paul Callan for The Daily Express

"While lushly orchestrated (by David Cullen with Mr. Lloyd Webber), the score is, for the most part, so slow that you have time to anticipate Mr. Slater’s next leaden rhyme. Each of the songs — which range from bathing-beauty frolics to power-chord operetta ballads — spins a single tune until it loses its tread."
Ben Brantley for The New York Times

"Frequently clunky and clumsy...Lloyd Webber's score, too, seems like a rehashed parade of pastiche and throbbing crashing-chord melodies."
Mark Shenton for Entertainment Weekly

"Watching the sequel only makes you appreciate the achievement of the original."
David Benedict for Variety

"The musical is impressive and enjoyable, even with its heavy hokum and creakiest of plots."
Warwick Thompson for Bloomberg News

Dix ans après la disparition mystérieuse du Fantôme de l'opéra de Paris, Christine Daaé accepte une offre mystérieuse l'invitant à venir en Amérique pour chanter dans le nouveau et fabuleux lieu de plaisir New-Yorkais, Coney Island. Arrivant à New York avec son mari Raoul et leur fils, Gustave, Christine découvre bientôt l'identité de l'imprésario anonyme qui l'a leurrée…

Synopsis complet

The musical opened with previews on 22nd February 2010, originally directed by Jack O’Brien and with lyrics by Glenn Slater. Although it was praised for its lavish staging, and received a few excellent notices, it was generally felt to be clunky and exceptionally dark and gloomy. It was rapidly nicknamed “Paint Never Dries”. Later in the year a new version was rehearsed simultaneously with the evening performances and the show closed for four days in November 2010 for substantial re-writes. It re-opened with new direction from Bill Kenwright, new choreography from Bill Deamer, and some new lyrics by Charles Hart. The London production closed on 27 August 2011 after a disappointing run of fewer than eighteen months.
A heavily re-written Australian production with a new production team opened in Melbourne in May 2011 and transferred to Sydney in January 2012 and was considered to be a great success.


Andrew Lloyd Webber first began plans for a sequel to his 1986 hit musical, The Phantom of the Opera, in 1990. Following a conversation with Maria Björnson, the designer of The Phantom of the Opera, Lloyd Webber decided that, were a sequel to come about, it would be set in New York City at the turn of the 20th century. One of his ideas was to have Phantom live above ground in Manhattan's first penthouse, but he rejected this when he saw a TV documentary about the Coney Island fairground. Lloyd Webber began collaborating with author Frederick Forsyth on the project, but it soon fell apart as Lloyd Webber felt the ideas they were developing would be difficult to adapt for a stage musical. Forsyth went on to publish some of the ideas he had worked on with Lloyd Webber in 1999 as a novel entitled The Phantom of Manhattan.

Lloyd Webber returned to the project in 2006, collaborating with a number of writers and directors. However, he still did not feel the ideas he had were adaptable into a piece of musical theatre. Finally, in early 2007, Lloyd Webber approached Ben Elton (who had served as the librettist for Lloyd Webber's The Beautiful Game) to help shape a synopsis for a sequel, based on Lloyd Webber's initial ideas. Elton's treatment of the story focused more on the original characters of The Phantom of the Opera and omitted new characters that Lloyd Webber and Forsyth had developed. Lloyd Webber was pleased with Elton's treatment and began work on the sequel. In March 2007, he announced he would be moving forward with the project.

The Daily Mail announced in May 2007 that the sequel would be delayed, because Lloyd Webber's six-month-old kitten Otto, a rare-breed Turkish Van, climbed onto Lloyd Webber's Clavinova digital piano and managed to delete the entire score. Lloyd Webber was unable to recover any of it from the instrument, but was eventually able to reconstruct the score. In 2008, Lloyd Webber first announced that the sequel would likely be called Phantom: Once Upon Another Time, and the first act was performed at Lloyd Webber's annual Sydmonton Festival. The Phantom was played by Ramin Karimloo and Raoul was played by Alistair Robbins. However, in September 2008, during the BBC's Birthday in the Park concert celebrating his 60th birthday, Lloyd Webber announced that the title would be Love Never Dies. In other workshop readings, Raoul and Christine were played by Aaron Lazar and Elena Shaddow.

On 3 July 2009, Lloyd Webber announced that Karimloo (who had played the Phantom in the West End) and Sierra Boggess (who had originated the role of Christine in Phantom – The Las Vegas Spectacular) had been cast as the Phantom and Christine and that the role of Meg Giry would be played by Summer Strallen, Madame Giry by Liz Robertson and Raoul by Joseph Millson. I'd Do Anything finalist Niamh Perry was given the role of Fleck.

Lloyd Webber originally intended for Love Never Dies to open in London, New York and Shanghai simultaneously in the autumn of 2009. By March 2009, he had decided to open the show at London's Adelphi Theatre, followed by Toronto's Royal Alexandra Theatre (before transferring to Broadway's Neil Simon Theatre in 2010) and Shanghai. The three casts would rehearse simultaneously in London for three months beginning August 2009. Opening dates were soon announced as 26 October 2009 in London, November in Toronto and February 2010 in Shanghai, with a later transfer to Melbourne, Australia. Plans were then announced for a separate Broadway production to run concurrently with the Toronto show if Toronto proved successful. In May, the debut of the London production was delayed until March 2010 due to Lloyd Webber re-orchestrating the score and re-recording the album. Technical issues with the special effects, automaton version of Christine and casting multiple simultaneous productions also contributed to the postponement. By October 2009, Shanghai plans had been dropped in favour of an Australian production.

On 8 October 2009, Lloyd Webber held a press conference at Her Majesty's Theatre, where the original Phantom has been running since 1986, confirming the casting of Boggess as Christine and Karimloo as the Phantom. Karimloo sang "Til I Hear You Sing", and "The Coney Island Waltz" was also performed for the journalists, industry insiders and fans who had assembled for the presentation. Lloyd Webber announced that Love Never Dies would begin previews in London on 20 February 2010 and anticipated that the Broadway production would open on 11 November 2010 (this was later postponed[30] and then indefinitely). Rehearsals began in January 2010.

West End (2010–2011)
The first preview of Love Never Dies was delayed from 20 February to 22 February 2010 due to a last-minute brief illness of Boggess and technical demands. The show had its official opening on 9 March 2010. It was directed by Jack O'Brien, choreographed by Jerry Mitchell, and had set and costume designs by Bob Crowley.[5] The cast included Ramin Karimloo as the Phantom, Sierra Boggess as Christine, Joseph Millson as Raoul, Liz Robertson as Madame Giry, Summer Strallen as Meg Giry and Niamh Perry as Fleck. In April 2010, Lloyd Webber was threatened with a £20,000 fine for illegally painting the Grade II-listed Adelphi Theatre black to promote this musical.
In December 2010, Lloyd Webber closed the London production for a few days to rework the show after a poor critical response. The musical was reviewed again (at Lloyd Webber's invitation), with critic Henry Hitchings noting that "Some of the most obvious alterations stem from the recruitment of lyricist Charles Hart to adjust the cadences of the original clunky lines written by Glenn Slater." He further pointed out that "There are also lots of bracing directorial touches; the show is credited to Jack O’Brien, but it is new choreographer Bill Deamer and producer Bill Kenwright who have added the zest." The London production closed on 27 August 2011 after a disappointing run of fewer than eighteen months. In 2012, Lloyd Webber stated that although he was, "very, very proud" of the London production, it did not completely work and also said, "something just went slightly wrong; I had cancer just before the production, and it was just that crucial 5% off-beam".
The hoped-for Broadway production was announced as delayed to spring 2011. Lloyd Webber also announced that Asian and Canadian productions were planned, although these have been dropped for now. After the mixed reviews and negative reaction from some Phantom fans during previews, an executive producer stated that before its bow on Broadway, the show would likely undergo "some changes". On October 1, 2010 it was announced that the musical would not open on Broadway in Spring 2011.

Melbourne (2011)
In 2010, Lloyd-Webber announced that the Australian production would open on May 21, 2011 at Melbourne's Regent Theatre. This production, the first outside of the UK, featured brand new direction and design by an Australian creative team, including director Simon Phillips. Ben Lewis and Anna O'Byrne were cast as the leads, Although Lloyd Webber hopes to bring the Melbourne production to Broadway in the future, he told The New York Times that, even with the positive reception of the reworked Melbourne production, a Broadway transfer was probably not realistic. He also announced that the Melbourne production would be filmed on September 15, 2011 and made available on DVD. The recording was originally to be released on DVD and Blu-ray February 1, 2012, but it was later delayed till May 29, 2012 in the United States. In the UK, the DVD was released on March 12, 2012, and in Australia it was released on February 8, 2012. The recorded performance also played in select theaters on February 28 and March 7, 2012. It was then screened again in U.S. cinemas on May 23, 2012. Lloyd Webber stated that even if a Broadway production does not happen, he feels that he has closed the chapter on the piece, as the filmed version is something that he's, "very, very proud of" and it does not really matter to him, "if it comes tomorrow or five years' time". The Melbourne production closed on December 18, 2011.

Sydney (2012)
The Melbourne production transferred to Sydney's Capitol Theatre with previews beginning January 8, 2012 and officially opened on January 12, 2012. The show concluded its limited engagement on April 1, 2012.

Copenhagen (2012)
Det Ny Teater in Copenhagen, Denmark announced that their production of Love Never Dies will open on October 24, 2012. Starring danish coloratura soprano Louise Fribo as Christine.


The Concept Album
The Original Concept Album was released in March 2010. It peaked at number 10 on the UK Albums Chart, #1 in Greece, #8 in New Zealand and #15 in Denmark.
The following musical numbers are how they appeared on that original album.

Disc 1
"Prologue"
"The Coney Island Waltz"
"That's the Place That You Ruined, You Fool!"
"Heaven by the Sea"
"Only for Him/Only for You"
"The Aerie"
"'Til I Hear You Sing"
"Giry Confronts the Phantom/'Til I Hear You Sing (Reprise)"
"Christine Disembarks"
"Arrival of the Trio/"Are You Ready to Begin?"
"What a Dreadful Town!..."
"Look with Your Heart"
"Beneath a Moonless Sky"
"Once Upon Another Time"
"Mother Please, I'm Scared!"
"Dear Old Friend"
"Beautiful"
"The Beauty Underneath"
"The Phantom Confronts Christine"

Disc 2
"Entr'acte"
"Why Does She Love Me?"
"Devil Take the Hindmost"
"Heaven by the Sea (Reprise)"
"Ladies...Gents!/The Coney Island Waltz (Reprise)"
"Bathing Beauty"
"Mother, Did You Watch?"
"Before the Performance"
"Devil Take the Hindmost" (Quartet)
"Love Never Dies"
"Ah, Christine!"
"Gustave! Gustave!"
"Please Miss Giry, I Want to Go Back!..."

London
The Original London production opened with all the songs from the Concept Album. However, the show went through several rewrites and many of the songs were rearranged or even removed from the production. Charles Hart, one of the original lyricists from Phantom of the Opera, was brought in to help in the rewrites. These are the musical numbers as they last appeared in the London Production.

Act I
"'Til I Hear You Sing" – The Phantom
"The Coney Island Waltz" – The Orchestra
"Only for You" – Meg Giry, Fleck, Squelch, Gangle and Ensemble
"Ten Long Years" (Duet) – Meg and Madame Giry
"Christine Disembarks" – Raoul, Gustave and Ensemble
"Are You Ready to Begin?" – Fleck, Gangle, Squelch, Raoul, Gustave and Ensemble
"What a Dreadful Town!" – Raoul, Christine and Gustave
"Look with Your Heart" – Christine and Gustave
"Beneath a Moonless Sky" – Christine and The Phantom
"Once Upon Another Time" – Christine and The Phantom
"Mother Please, I'm Scared!" – The Phantom, Gustave and Christine
"Ten Long Years of Yearning" – The Phantom and Christine
"Dear Old Friend" – Meg, Madame Giry, Christine, Raoul, Gustave and Ensemble
"Beautiful" – Gustave, Fleck, Gangle, Squelch and The Phantom
"The Beauty Underneath" – The Phantom and Gustave
"Phantom Confronts Christine" – The Phantom, Christine and Madame Giry

Act II
Entr'acte – The Orchestra
"Why Does She Love Me?" – Raoul, Meg and Ensemble
"Devil Take the Hindmost" – Raoul and The Phantom
"Invitation to the Concert" – Fleck, Gangle, Squelch and Ensemble
"Bathing Beauty" – Meg, Fleck, Gangle, Squelch and Ensemble
"Before the Performance" – Christine, Raoul, Gustave and The Phantom
"Devil Take the Hindmost" (Quartet) – Gustave, Raoul, The Phantom, Madame Giry and Meg
"Love Never Dies" – Christine
"Ah, Christine!" – The Phantom and Christine
"Gustave! Gustave!" – Christine, The Phantom, Madame Giry, Fleck, Gangle and Squelch
"Please Miss Giry, I Want to Go Back" – Gustave and Meg
Finale – The Phantom and Christine
Playout – Orchestra

Melbourne/Sydney
The Original (reworked) Australian production opened with many of the songs from the reworked London production with new staging. Staging and musical numbers for the Australian Production:

Act I
"Til I Hear You Sing" (includes "The Aerie") – The Phantom
"The Coney Island Waltz" – Squelch, Fleck, Gangle & Ensemble
"Only for You" – Meg Giry, Ensemble
"Ten Long Years" (Duet) – Meg and Madame Giry
"Christine Disembarks" – Raoul, Gustave and Ensemble
"Are You Ready to Begin?" – Fleck, Gangle, Squelch, Raoul, Gustave and Ensemble
"What a Dreadful Town!" – Raoul, Christine and Gustave
"Look with Your Heart" – Christine and Gustave
"Beneath a Moonless Sky" – Christine and The Phantom
"Once Upon Another Time" – Christine and The Phantom
"Mother Please, I'm Scared!" – The Phantom, Gustave and Christine
"Ten Long Years of Yearning" – The Phantom and Christine
"Dear Old Friend" – Meg, Madame Giry, Christine, Raoul, Gustave and Ensemble
"Beautiful" – Gustave, Fleck, Gangle, Squelch and The Phantom
"The Beauty Underneath" – The Phantom and Gustave
"Phantom Confronts Christine" – The Phantom, Christine and Madame Giry

Act II
Entr'acte – The Orchestra
"Why Does She Love Me?" – Raoul, Meg and Ensemble
"Devil Take the Hindmost" – Raoul and The Phantom
"Invitation to the Concert" – Fleck, Gangle, Squelch and Ensemble
"Bathing Beauty" – Meg, Fleck, Gangle, Squelch and Ensemble
"Before the Performance" – Christine, Raoul, Gustave and The Phantom
"Devil Take the Hindmost" (Reprise) – Gustave, Raoul, The Phantom, Madame Giry and Meg
"Love Never Dies" – Christine
"Ah, Christine!" – The Phantom and Christine
"Gustave! Gustave!" – Christine, The Phantom, Madame Giry, Fleck, Gangle and Squelch
"Please Miss Giry, I Want to Go Back" – Gustave and Meg
Finale – The Phantom and Christine
"Love Never Dies" (Reprise) - The Phantom
Playout – Orchestra

Aucun dossier informatif complémentaire concernant Love never dies

While Andrew Lloyd Webber claims that the show takes place ten years after the original, it has actually been 26 years (from 1881 to 1907).
Shortly after the London production opened, a Broadway production was announced to open at the Neil Simon Theatre in November 2010. Because of lukewarm reviews in London and problems with the creative team, the Broadway opening was postponed. Lloyd Webber expressed enthusiasm for the Australian production in May 2011 and stated his intention to use the Australian version for future productions, including the proposed Broadway production.

As with Phantom, Lloyd Webber's score for Love Never Dies also includes the fictional music of its time as musical fragments to fictional pieces which are taking place within the show itself. Only "Bathing Beauty" survived the post concept album cuts to be performed on stage.
Instead of the operatic passages for fictional "operas," the "stage" music at Phantasma is based on the companion pieces to the Savoy Operas, which were often burlesques and were also sometimes performed at the Opéra Comique. Many of these kinds of burlesques were based on existing French operas. During the Victorian age, nearly every popular opera was turned into a burlesque.[34] The W. S. Gilbert (of Gilbert and Sullivan) operatic burlesque Robert the Devil is a parody of Robert le diable, a romantic grand opera by Meyerbeer which was mentioned in the opening to "Phantom of the Opera".
These pieces were very popular among the lower class, but not commonly seen by more sophisticated opera goers. According to W. J. MacQueen-Pope: "This was a one-act play, seen only by the early comers. It would play to empty boxes, half-empty upper circle, to a gradually filling stalls and dress circle, but to an attentive, grateful and appreciative pit and gallery. Often these plays were little gems. They deserved much better treatment than they got, but those who saw them delighted in them. ... [They] served to give young actors and actresses a chance to win their spurs ... the stalls and the boxes lost much by missing the curtain-raiser, but to them dinner was more important."
Like most burlesques, "Robert the Devil" featured women in scanty costumes and breeches roles. In operas, these were always supporting roles. The pageboy role in Christine's second opera is a breeches role, like the part of Cherubino, the Count's page, in The Marriage of Figaro. However, in burlesques, breeches roles could be main parts.
Very little specific information is available for most of these curtain openers. However, the opener for "Pinafore", which had also been performed at the Opéra Comique in 1878, was called "Beauties on the Beach".[36] Meg Giry's grand opening number in "Love Never Dies" is called "Bathing Beauty (On The Beach)".


Version 1

Love never dies (2010-03-Adelphi Theatre-London)

Type de série: Original
Théâtre: Adelphi Theatre (Londres - Angleterre)
Durée : 1 an 5 mois 2 semaines
Nombre :
Première Preview : lundi 22 février 2010
Première : mardi 09 mars 2010
Dernière : samedi 27 août 2011
Mise en scène : Jack O'Brien
Chorégraphie : Jerry Mitchell
Producteur :
Avec : Ramin Karimloo (Phantom ), Sierra Boggess (Christine Daaé), Joseph Millson (Raoul), Liz Robertson (Mme Giry), Summer Strallen (Meg), Niamh Perry (Fleck), Adam Pearce (Squelch), Jami Reid-Quarrell (Gangle)
Commentaires : The musical opened with previews on 22nd February 2010, originally directed by Jack O’Brien and with lyrics by Glenn Slater. Although it was praised for its lavish staging, and received a few excellent notices, it was generally felt to be clunky and exceptionally dark and gloomy. It was rapidly nicknamed “Paint Never Dries”. Later in the year a new version was rehearsed simultaneously with the evening performances and the show closed for four days in November 2010 for substantial re-writes. It re-opened with new direction from Bill Kenwright, new choreography from Bill Deamer, and some new lyrics by Charles Hart. The London production closed on 27 August 2011 after a disappointing run of fewer than eighteen months.
Presse : "There is much to enjoy in Andrew Lloyd Webber's new musical. The score is one of the composer's most seductive. Bob Crowley's design and Jack O'Brien's direction have a beautiful kaleidoscopic fluidity. And the performances are good. The problems lie within the book, chiefly credited to Lloyd Webber himself and Ben Elton, which lacks the weight to support the imaginative superstructure...In short, the show has much to commend it and the staging is a constant source of iridescent pleasure. But, as one of the lyrics reminds us, 'diamonds never sparkle bright unless they are set just right'. Although Lloyd Webber's score is full of gems, in the end a musical is only as good as its book. With a libretto to match the melodies, this might have been a stunner rather than simply a good night out."
Michael Billington for The Guardian

"Dismally implausible plot...The blogosphere has been teeming with views of Lloyd Webber’s long-awaited Phantom II. For some, Love Never Dies is 'Paint Never Dries', and for others the composer is at his musical best. I tend to agree with both factions....Bob Crowley (Designs] successfully evokes much of Phantasma, helped by projections of spooky horses on carousels. Yet that’s all rather cursory, as is the choreography, which doesn’t amount to a lot more than the inevitable bathing beauties bouncing about on the beach. "
Benedict Nightingale for The Times

"Lloyd Webber’s finest show since the original Phantom, with a score blessed with superbly haunting melodies and a yearning romanticism that sent shivers racing down my spine....The show may ultimately prove too strange, too dark, too tormented to become a massive popular hit, but I suspect its creepy allure will linger potently in the memory when frothier shows have been long forgotten. "
The Daily Telegraph

"What is in no doubt is the technical excellence of Jack O'Brien's seamlessly fluent, sumptuous (and sometimes subtle) production, or the splendour of the orchestra which pours forth Lloyd Webber's dark-hued, yearning melodies as if its life depended on them."
Paul Taylor for The Independent

"It doesn’t really smoke into life until the 20th minute and even then it splutters for a while. Finally, the singing and the ingenious staging combine to show the Lloyd Webber orchestration to its full glory, but, boy, it takes an age."
Quentin Letts for The Daily Mail

"While Lloyd Webber’s music is at times lavishly operatic, the tone is uneven. There are no more than a couple of songs that promise to live in the memory, the duets don’t soar, and the ending is insipid. Admirers of Phantom are likely to be disappointed, and there’s not enough here to entice a new generation of fans."
Henry Hitchings for The Evening Standard

"Sets and special effects cannot be faulted, the singing is terrific...a stunning ending. But phantastic? Afraid not."
Bill Hagerty for The Sun

"Musically, it is pleasing enough...Visually, the show is stunning in places."
Matthew Hemley for The Stage

"This is an elegant and clever sequel to Phantom...It is a great night out."
Paul Callan for The Daily Express

"While lushly orchestrated (by David Cullen with Mr. Lloyd Webber), the score is, for the most part, so slow that you have time to anticipate Mr. Slater’s next leaden rhyme. Each of the songs — which range from bathing-beauty frolics to power-chord operetta ballads — spins a single tune until it loses its tread."
Ben Brantley for The New York Times

"Frequently clunky and clumsy...Lloyd Webber's score, too, seems like a rehashed parade of pastiche and throbbing crashing-chord melodies."
Mark Shenton for Entertainment Weekly

"Watching the sequel only makes you appreciate the achievement of the original."
David Benedict for Variety

"The musical is impressive and enjoyable, even with its heavy hokum and creakiest of plots."
Warwick Thompson for Bloomberg News

Version 2

Love never dies (2011-05-Regent Theatre-Melbourne)

Type de série: Revival
Théâtre: Regent Theatre (Melbourne - Australie)
Durée : 6 mois 3 semaines
Nombre :
Première Preview : samedi 21 mai 2011
Première : dimanche 29 mai 2011
Dernière : dimanche 18 décembre 2011
Mise en scène : Simon Phillips
Chorégraphie : Graeme Murphy
Producteur :
Avec : The Phantom ... Ben Lewis / Christine Daaé ... Anna O’Byrne / Raoul, Vicomte de Chagny ... Simon Gleeson / Madame Giry ... Maria Mercedes / Meg Giry ... Sharon Millerchip / Fleck ... Emma J. Hawkins / Squelch ... Paul Tabone / Gangle ... Dean Vince
Commentaires : The Australian production was not a carbon copy of the 2010 London production, and instead has new design and a new director. Simon Phillips directed, with Gabriela Tylesova designed.

Version 3

Love never dies (2012-01-Capitol Theatre-Sydney)

Type de série: Revival
Théâtre: Capitol Theatre (Sydney - Australie)
Durée : 2 mois 2 semaines
Nombre :
Première Preview : dimanche 08 janvier 2012
Première : jeudi 12 janvier 2012
Dernière : dimanche 01 avril 2012
Mise en scène : Simon Phillips
Chorégraphie : Graeme Murphy
Producteur :
Avec : The Phantom ... Ben Lewis / Christine Daaé ... Anna O’Byrne / Raoul, Vicomte de Chagny ... Simon Gleeson / Madame Giry ... Maria Mercedes / Meg Giry ... Sharon Millerchip / Fleck ... Emma J. Hawkins / Squelch ... Paul Tabone / Gangle ... Dean Vince
Commentaires : Il s'agit d'un transfert de la version qui venait de triompher à Melbourne. Très étonnement, pendant cette série à Sydney, le DVD de la version de Melbourne a été mis en vente dans le monde entier, mais aussi en Australie. Il est très rare qu'un DVD de musical soit diffusé alors que le spectacle se joue encore.

Version 4

Love never dies (2015-10-Operettenhaus-Hamburg)

Type de série: Revival
Théâtre: Operettenhaus (Hambourg - Allemagne)
Durée : 11 mois 2 semaines
Nombre :
Première Preview : jeudi 15 octobre 2015
Première : jeudi 15 octobre 2015
Dernière : dimanche 25 septembre 2016
Mise en scène : Simon Phillips
Chorégraphie : Graeme Murphy
Producteur :
Avec : Rachel Anne Moore (Christine Daaé), Gardar Thor Cortes (Das Phantom), Lauren Barrand (Fleck), Jak Allen-Anderson (Gangle), Masha Karell (Madame Giry), Ina Trabesinger (Meg Giry), Yngve Gasoy-Romdal (Raoul Vicomte de Chagny), Paul Tabone (Squelch)

 Pas encore de video disponible pour ce spectacle